BCG Matrix Advantages and Disadvantages

In case of English we all have read letters BCD and in case of management, all management students read the letters BCG. BCG matrix is the term used in the context of management. Full form of BCG matrix is Boston Consulting Group Matrix. BCG matrix has four types of scenarios with respect to the market share of the company, cash flow generation and growth rate of the industry in which company is operating. The four quadrants or scenarios of BCG matrix are called stars, cash cows, question marks, and dogs.

BCG Matrix 4 Quadrants

Stars is the first quadrant which represents those business units which have higher market share in a rapidly growing industry which results in higher cash inflow for the company, while cash cows is the second quadrant which represents those business units which have higher market share in stable industry resulting in higher cash inflow for the company without much of investment. Question marks is the third quadrant which represents those business units which are having lower market share in a rapidly growing market and it requires substantial investment on the part of the company, while the last quadrant is called dogs which represent those business units which have low market share and industry too is on the declining trend which leaves no scope for company to have good cash flows. In order to have a clear understanding of this concept one should look at advantages and disadvantages of BCG Matrix

BCG Matrix Advantages

Easy to Understand

The biggest advantage of BCG matrix is that it very easy to understand and one does not need to have a master’s degree or qualification to understand this concept. Hence anyone who is seeing this matrix can deduce easily that cash cow and stars are the two quadrants which are ideal for the company and question marks and dog are the two quadrants which a company should try to avoid due to the risks involved in both the scenarios.

Identification of Opportunities

Another advantage of this matrix is that it helps the company in identification of opportunities because once dog and question marks quadrants are removed company is left with only cash cows and stars quadrants and depending on company cash position and risk appetite it can either go for stars business units which have high scope of growth but at the same time requires substantial investment on the part of the company or it can go for cash cows business units which provide good cash inflow with minimal investment, however, their growth is not at the same level as stars business units.

Helpful in Removing the Weak area of Business

It is helpful in removing the weak business units because once the company has identified dogs and question mark business units than it can save a lot of money by not investing further money into dogs business units rather company can sell such business units and invest that money elsewhere profitably. As far as question marks business units are concerned if the company has excess cash than it can invest that money into question marks units because such units have potential to gain but they require patience as well money from the company.

BCG Matrix Disadvantages

Ignores other Factors of Business

The biggest problem with this approach is that it takes into account market share and cash flows only into account and ignores other factors of business which are equally important for success. Hence if the company has selected cash cows or stars business units but if the top management is not good or employees are not dedicated or some natural calamity happens than also company will be making a loss. Hence choosing stars and cash cows do not guarantee that company will make profits only.

Simplistic Approach for a Complex situation

Another problem with this matrix is that it offers simplistic approach for handling complex situation of selecting business units as business units are complex structures and by paying attention to only three factors that is cash flows, growth rate, and market share and ignoring the rest of the factors this matrix may not provide ideal solution for every situation.

No Middle Path

Another limitation of this approach is that it does not have a middle path that is it is not necessary that business is high growth or low growth as some business can also be of moderate growth and for such business this matrix offers no solution. Besides some business units are of strategic importance to the company and company cannot shut or sell it just because it falls under question marks or dogs category.

As one can see from the above that BCG matrix has pros as well as cons and any company thinking of adopting this strategy should carefully read above points and then decide whether to select or sell business unit based on the analysis done through BCG matrix.

0 comments… add one

Leave a Comment

Related pages

payback period definition pdfthe concept of diminishing marginal utilityadvantages and disadvantages of privatization pdffull form slrdupont equation analysisprepayment journal entryimplications of capmpenetration pricing examples productsadvantages and disadvantages of forecastingmoney market hedge advantages disadvantagesglobalisation disadvantagesdisadvantage of mixed economyexamples of direct taxesdisadvantages globalizationfeatures of perfect competition in economicsadvantages of fifo methodprepaid expenses journal entriescomplementry goodsprepaid expenses journal entry examplecharacteristics of an oligopolyadvantages and disadvantages of future contractstransfer pricing advantages disadvantageswhat is the law of diminishing utilityconsumer durables exampleswhat is the difference between crr and slrwhen is a trial balance preparedcash discount journal entrywhat is the difference between job costing and process costingfluctuating exchange rateconglomerate company examplesdepreciation declining balance methodpredetermine definitionselling shares advantages and disadvantagescommodity swap examplehorizontal merger and acquisitionhedgers in derivative marketdefinition of skimming pricingadvantages and disadvantages of industrial agricultureconglomerate mergersadjusting entry for unearned revenueadvantages and disadvantages of public corporationexplain the law of diminishing returnsadvantages and disadvantages of functional organizational structureunbilled revenue meaningwhat is full form of cfadefinition of durable goodhorizontal analysis definitionwhat are the drawbacks of democracyoutstanding salary journal entrywhat is the meaning of demand draftppf advantagesexample of diminishing marginal utilitydifference between accounts receivable and bills receivableexample of elastic goodsproduct bundling pricingproblems of barter systemfull form fdiadvantages and disadvantages of takeovers and mergerswhat is the difference between accounting profit and economic profitadvantages and disadvantages of nationalisationmateriality accountingadvantages and disadvantages of working capitaldefine cost push inflationdemerits of globalisationwhat are the advantages of a traditional economyunitarily elasticwhat is the difference between systematic risk and unsystematic riskdirect expenses and indirect expensestypes of liquidity ratioprogressive tax advantagesdifferentiate between socialism and capitalismadvantages and disadvantages of international businessadvantages and disadvantages of lifo methodbundling pricing strategy